January 7, 2021: Yesterday
Yesterday was the 12th day of Christmas, also the Feast of the Epiphany, which is a date some Episcopalians use for “time to take the tree down now.” It’s not doctrine, and in our house, the tree comes down whenever it’s convenient, but Epiphany sounded perfect. Warnock had been declared, we were waiting on Ossoff, I posted that great dance video, I dialed up a chipper podcast I wanted to listen to – not a politics podcast, even - and we got the ornaments off and packed into their boxes. It was time to start on the lights.
Then all hell broke loose. And that was all she wrote.
Ye gods.
If you think I have some unique and wonderful insight into
yesterday, I don’t. I did say to my husband, last week, “Do you think something
Really Really Bad is going to happen on January 6th?” It wasn’t a
premonition, more like, “Given the way Trump is behaving, and the way the
Republicans in Congress are not standing up to him, and the way he’s got his
bad guys riled, isn’t it more than likely?”
I mean, I called the subprime mortgage crisis of 2008. It
wasn’t rocket science.
Anyway, the first crop of good takes on yesterday are out
there. Stephen Colbert is brilliant, as is Seth Meyers, as is Heather Cox
Richardson as is Jimmy Kimmel as is Alexandra Petri as is… you know. If you
want a take, you know where to find takes. You probably have favorite places
you go. If you don’t have favorite places, try one of these, or the one at the
end.
Colbert asking Republican supporters of Trump if America is great again yet –
not long
Meyers calling for Trump’s removal – not long
Richardson about the coup attempt and the Confederate flag - an hour long, brilliant, and worth every minute
Kimmel in his Treason Finale – not long, and do stick around to the end
Petri on "we love you, you're very special" – short and sweet
Hey, I have a question. You know that shaming trope, “When
your grandchildren ask you what you did to stand up to autocracy, what will you
tell them?” Well, that’s not my
question.
My question is: Did you, personally, ever ask your
grandparents what they did in the war, or in the Cold War, or in any historical
moment? Did you? Did you listen raptly and either boo or applaud them?
I think I asked my dad about World War II and I got a little
bit of an answer, but it was about the utter stupidity of war. Then man had
medals. He was a Marine. He didn’t want to talk about it. The weird thing about
the trope, to me, is that it suggests we had all better act honorably now, just
so that on some distant date, we can pass muster with our judgey progeny.
It’s so strange, is all. It’s echoed by so many who are
saying, of the Republicans - either the silent enablers or the expicit co-conspirators - that history will judge them harshly. What the heck?! I judge them harshly
right now. Come on down and join me!
Also, there’s another shaming trope: The world is laughing
at us. I don’t know exactly why this always strikes me as The Least of Our
Problems, but it does. It’s like we’re saying to a toddler, Don’t torture
animals in front of the NEIGHBORS! But our embarrassment isn’t the issue. The fact
that our kid is torturing animals is the issue.
I heard from several of my overseas pals yesterday, and they
weren’t laughing, if that’s any comfort. I did get a little prickly with one
who seemed to be piling on, but I managed to ask for clarification and learn
that her country is under some pretty scary leadership right now, too. So she
gets a pass. I sent her a very short Adam Gopnik think piece from The New
Yorker about America’s crisis of democracy.
I have felt better hearing from all of these thinkers, but
the Gopnik piece was the one that resonated the most. And it wasn’t even
written yesterday.
Today I'm reading and listening and pretty much sunk in yesterday, and writing to politicians, urging them to invoke the 25th Amendment. (What did you do after Trump incited insurrection, Grandma? Oh, I sent emails and texts! POSTCARDS! I wrote postcards!) And when I put that aside, I'm thinking of getting the lights off the tree.

that history will judge them harshly. What the heck?! I judge them harshly right now. Come on down and join me!
ReplyDeleteIndeed
That "history will judge them" thing is like a variation on "Just wait until your dad gets home!" In a way....
DeleteI understand it in some ways. It asks that you think about things in ways that are not just about yourself and your current level of comfort or lack of concern because this horrible thing “doesn’t affect me”. It’s a variation on the old “first they came for...” saw. “I never liked/voted for Dotard” won’t cut it 10 years from now any more than “I never really joined the Nazi party” was no evidence of anti-Nazi bona fides in post-WWII Germany. I don’t think “how will history see me” should be anyone’s first concern, but you should care what happens to those who will live after you. In as far as worrying what history will say is a function of that, it’s not a bad thing to consider
DeleteThanks. I appreciate that perspective.
Delete